Skip to main content
N53°49'N3°03'W52°30'N3°18'W18°44'N70°10'W50°00'N8°00'E46°00'N2°00'E65°00'N15°00'E32°00'N100°00'W37°00'N120°00'W34°00'N69°00'E52°00'S59°00'W64°00'N22°00'W72°00'N25°00'W36°00'N78°00'W25°00'N55°00'E35°30'N139°30'E1°00'N104°00'E34°00'S151°00'E
Jerry Can Spirits®

WELCOME, EXPLORER

Please confirm you are of legal drinking age in your region.

By entering, you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

A vintage watercolour illustration of a Painkiller in a carved tiki mug, a pale, creamy drink over ice, dusted with grated nutmeg and garnished with a pineapple wedge, with pineapple, coconut, orange and whole nutmeg around it, painted in warm, faded tones on aged parchment.

Painkiller

Novice

A Painkiller is 60ml of Pusser’s Rum, 120ml of pineapple juice, 30ml of fresh orange juice and 30ml of cream of coconut, given a hard 10 to 12 second shake and strained onto cubed ice in a tiki mug or a big glass, with fresh nutmeg grated on top. About 2.4 UK units. Cream of coconut is coconut and sugar, usually with no dairy, but check the label. The name belongs to Pusser’s. Pusser’s prints the name with the registered symbol on its own Painkiller page, and the Oxford Companion says the company owns the trademark for the Pusser’s Painkiller cocktail. The recipe here is its own: four parts pineapple, one of cream of coconut and one of orange, with Pusser’s to suit. Difford’s Guide says it trademarked the name in the United States and the UK in 2003 and in 2010 forced a New York bar called Painkiller to rename itself PKNY. Pusser’s traces the drink to Daphne Henderson’s Soggy Dollar Bar on Jost Van Dyke, in the British Virgin Islands.

ShakenLong DrinkTikiPartyCelebratoryClassic

Ingredients

Serves
Pusser's Rum

60ml

The rum the name belongs to, and the one Pusser’s specifies: a dark, full-bodied blend in the British naval style. Pusser’s says to add rum to suit; 60ml is its standard measure.

Pineapple juice

120ml

Pressed or not-from-concentrate juice, chilled. At 120ml it makes up half the glass, so a thin, sugary carton shows at once.

Fresh orange juice

30ml

Squeezed the same day. Its acid keeps the coconut from making the drink heavy.

Cream of coconut

30ml

Sweetened cream of coconut, such as Coco López. It separates in the tin, so stir or shake it before measuring. There is usually no dairy in it, but check the label.

Instructions

1

Squeeze the orange juice the same day.

2

Fill a tiki mug or large glass of 450ml or more with cubed ice.

3

Add the rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and cream of coconut to a shaker with cubed ice.

4

Shake hard for 10 to 12 seconds.

5

Strain over the fresh ice.

6

Grate fresh nutmeg over the top and garnish with a pineapple wedge.

Source: the producer's own specification (Pusser’s: four parts pineapple, one part cream of coconut, one part orange juice, Pusser’s Rum to suit (60ml); garnish and method ours). Last checked 9 October 2026.

Expert Tip

Shake hard for the full 10 to 12 seconds. Cream of coconut is thick, and a short shake leaves it in streaks, so one sip tastes sweet and the next thin. Buy cream of coconut, not coconut cream. Cream of coconut is sweetened and made for drinks; coconut cream is unsweetened and made for cooking, and it leaves the glass savoury and short of sugar. Grate a whole nutmeg over the finished drink. Pre-ground nutmeg keeps little scent, and the smell at the rim is much of what a Painkiller offers.

The story

Behind the Painkiller

Flavour Profile

PineappleCoconutNutmegOrangeRich

The Origin

Pusser’s tells the story this way. The Soggy Dollar Bar sits on White Bay on Jost Van Dyke, in the British Virgin Islands, and its owner, Daphne Henderson, served a Painkiller whose recipe she kept to herself. The bar’s name is usually explained by customers swimming ashore with wet banknotes.

Charles Tobias, who founded Pusser’s after gaining the Admiralty Board’s permission in 1979 to sell the Royal Navy’s rum, got one of her drinks back to his boat and worked out his own version, by the company’s own account. He settled on four parts pineapple, one of cream of coconut and one of orange, with rum to suit.

The Trade Mark

Pusser’s prints the name with the registered symbol on its own Painkiller page, and the Oxford Companion says the company owns the trademark for the Pusser’s Painkiller cocktail. We have read no register entry.

Difford’s Guide says Pusser’s trademarked the name in the United States and the UK in 2003, and in 2010 forced the Lower East Side tiki bar Painkiller to rename itself PKNY after a cease-and-desist notice and a lawsuit. It had registered the name under bar and restaurant services as well as alcoholic beverages.

We give the drink as Pusser’s publishes it, with its rum, because the name and the recipe are both theirs.

Cream of Coconut

Cream of coconut is sweetened coconut, thick and syrupy, made for drinks. Coconut cream is the unsweetened, fatty layer from coconut milk, made for cooking. They look alike in the tin and behave very differently in a glass.

Coco López, from Puerto Rico, is the brand most bars reach for. It separates as it stands, so stir or shake the tin before measuring.

Pusser’s Proportions Against Ours

The Painkiller as Pusser’s publishes it and as we serve it

Pusser’s Rum

Pusser’s
60ml, or to suit
Ours
60ml

Pineapple juice

Pusser’s
120ml
Ours
120ml

Orange juice

Pusser’s
30ml
Ours
30ml, squeezed the same day

Cream of coconut

Pusser’s
30ml
Ours
30ml

Method

Pusser’s
Shaken, poured into a big glass of ice
Ours
Shaken 10 to 12 seconds, strained over fresh ice

Garnish

Pusser’s
Orange slice, cherry, fresh nutmeg
Ours
Pineapple wedge, fresh nutmeg

The measures are Pusser’s own. We strain over fresh ice and trade the orange slice and cherry for a pineapple wedge.

The Nutmeg

Nutmeg’s aroma sits in oils that fade soon after grinding. Grated fresh over the finished drink, it puts that scent at the rim, where it reaches you before the coconut and rum.

Pre-ground nutmeg adds a dusty brown speck and little else. A small fine grater and one whole nut last for dozens of drinks.

How to Serve It

Shaken hard and strained over fresh ice in a tiki mug or large glass, with nutmeg grated on top and a pineapple wedge on the rim. Hand it over straight away, before the ice thins the coconut.

The blended relation is the Piña Colada, with no orange and no nutmeg.

Make it

Make it at home

The Spirit

Dark Rum

Dark rum is a heavy, deep-coloured rum, counted at 40% ABV in our recipes, whose colour may come from years in oak, from blending or from added caramel, which Regulation (EC) 110/2008 allows. It brings weight and a burnt-sugar note to punches, hot drinks and tiki builds: the Rum Runner, the Hurricane and the Planter’s Punch.

Learn more
Go further

More to explore

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a Painkiller?

A rum drink from the British Virgin Islands: Pusser’s Rum, pineapple juice, orange juice and cream of coconut, shaken and served over ice with grated nutmeg. Pusser’s publishes it as four parts pineapple to one each of cream of coconut and orange, with rum to suit.

Do you have to use Pusser’s Rum in a Painkiller?

To call it a Painkiller, Pusser’s says yes. The Oxford Companion says Pusser’s owns the trademark for the Pusser’s Painkiller cocktail. Difford’s Guide says a trademark protects a drink’s name, not its ingredients, though in 2010 Pusser’s used its trademark to make a New York bar drop the name Painkiller.

Who invented the Painkiller?

Pusser’s credits the Soggy Dollar Bar on Jost Van Dyke, owned by Daphne Henderson, who would not share her recipe. By the company’s account, its founder Charles Tobias got one of her drinks back to his boat and his kitchen on Tortola and worked out his own version, four parts pineapple to one each of cream of coconut and orange.

How does it differ from a Piña Colada?

The orange juice and the ice. A Piña Colada is rum, pineapple and coconut, usually blended; the Painkiller adds fresh orange, which brings an acid the Colada lacks, and is shaken and served over ice. The nutmeg on top is the other difference.

Is cream of coconut the same as coconut cream?

No. Cream of coconut is sweetened and syrupy, made for drinks; Coco López is the familiar brand. Coconut cream is unsweetened and fatty, made for cooking. In a Painkiller the wrong one leaves the drink savoury and short of sugar.

How strong is a Painkiller?

About 2.4 UK units, all from 60ml of Pusser’s Rum taken at 40% ABV; Pusser’s stronger bottlings raise that. With 180ml of juice and coconut around it, it tastes much lighter than it is. UK units are ABV times millilitres divided by 1,000; the Chief Medical Officers’ guideline is no more than 14 units a week, spread over three or more days.

Is there dairy in a Painkiller?

Usually not. Cream of coconut is coconut and sugar, despite the word cream, and everything else is rum and juice. Some brands add other ingredients; read the tin if dairy matters. Anyone allergic to coconut should not drink it.

Sources.

Checked between 18 October and 19 October 2026.

  1. The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails (Richard Boccato), “The Painkiller” (secondary source: Pusser’s owns the trademark for the Pusser’s Painkiller cocktail; created at the Soggy Dollar Bar; the Myricks’ claim of 1971 against Pusser’s account; parentage left open).
  2. Pusser’s Rum, “Pusser’s Painkiller” (the company’s own account: Daphne Henderson, the Admiralty Board’s permission in 1979, Tobias’s kitchen on Tortola, the 4-1-1 ratio).
  3. Difford’s Guide, “Trademarking cocktails” (secondary source: Pusser’s trademarked the Painkiller in the US and UK in 2003; in 2010 the Lower East Side bar Painkiller was forced to rename itself PKNY; registered under several categories including restaurant and bar services).

You Might Also Like

Where this one sits

Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits · Updated 19 October 2026

Rate it

Enjoyed This Recipe?

First Pour

The book that comes before the bottle.

First Pour is our short companion to Expedition Spiced Rum. How it is built, how to drink it, and the first serves to try. Yours free, with 10% off your first order.