Skip to main content
The Old Standard cocktail recipe - Jerry Can Spirits

The Old Standard

Novice
Signature Cocktail

The Old Fashioned is the oldest documented cocktail format in the American canon and one of the most instructive templates available to any bartender who wants to understand what a base spirit is actually capable of. Strip everything back to spirit, sweetener, and bitters and the character of what is in the bottle has nowhere to hide. That unforgiving honesty is what makes the format worth applying to Expedition Spiced Rum. A spirit built with enough depth, warmth, and botanical complexity to carry the Old Standard without modification beyond the choice of sweetener and bitters. The demerara sugar syrup is the first considered departure from the conventional whiskey Old Fashioned. Where white sugar provides neutral sweetness that stays out of the way of the spirit, demerara brings its own molasses character, a raw, slightly mineral sweetness that sits in the same register as Expedition Spiced's Caribbean rum base and Welsh molasses foundation. The two reinforce each other rather than one simply sweetening the other. The split bitters follow the same logic. Angostura's clove and cinnamon reinforce the spice notes already present in the rum. A single dash of orange bitters picks up the orange peel in the botanical profile and lifts the nose of the finished drink in a way that Angostura alone does not achieve. The name is deliberate. Standards are not talked about at Jerry Can Spirits. They are lived. The Old Standard is a drink built entirely around that principle: every ingredient chosen for a specific reason, every decision traceable back to what the rum already is. Nothing added for convenience. Nothing omitted for speed.

High-ABVSpirit-ForwardBuiltStirredAfter-DinnerDigestifClassic

Glassware: Rocks Glass

Garnish: Orange peel

Ingredients

Serves
Jerry Can Spirits Expedition Spiced Rum

50ml

The foundation and the reason every other ingredient in this build was chosen. Its botanical profile of vanilla, cinnamon, allspice, clove, orange peel, cassia, ginger, agave, and bourbon oak defines the character of the finished drink from first sip to last.

Demerara sugar syrup

10ml

Two parts demerara sugar dissolved in one part warm water. The molasses character of demerara sits in the same register as the rum's Caribbean base and Welsh molasses foundation, reinforcing rather than simply sweetening.

Angostura bitters

2 dashes

Reinforces the clove and cinnamon already present in Expedition Spiced. Two dashes is the correct measure. More and the bitters compete with the rum's own spice rather than complementing it.

Orange bitters

1 dash

A single dash that picks up the orange peel in the rum's botanical profile and lifts the nose of the finished drink in a way that Angostura alone does not achieve.

Cubed ice

1 scoop for stirring 1 large cube for serving

Large clean cubes for stirring. A single large format cube for serving if available, melting slowly and keeping the drink cold without diluting it prematurely.

Orange peel

1 piece

Express the oils over the surface of the finished drink and rest inside the glass. Reinforces the orange peel in Expedition Spiced's botanical profile and changes the nose of every sip.

Instructions

1

Add the demerara sugar syrup, Angostura bitters, and orange bitters to a mixing glass.

2

Stir briefly to combine the syrup and bitters.

3

Add Expedition Spiced Rum and a scoop of large cubed ice.

4

Stir for 20 to 25 seconds until well chilled and properly diluted.

5

Strain over a single large ice cube or fresh cubed ice in a rocks glass.

6

Cut a wide strip of orange peel and express the oils over the surface of the drink.

7

Rest the peel inside the glass and serve immediately.

Expert Tip

The demerara syrup eliminates the risk of undissolved sugar sitting at the base of the glass, the most common point of failure in any Old Fashioned format. If you want to understand what it is contributing beyond simple sweetness, stir the syrup and bitters together and taste before the rum goes in. The molasses note is immediately apparent and explains why white sugar was never the right choice for this particular build.

Flavour Profile

SpicedVanillaAromaticRichCitrus

The Name

Standards are not talked about at Jerry Can Spirits. They are lived. The Old Standard is a drink that earns its name through the same discipline that defines the spirit it is built around: every ingredient chosen for a specific reason, every decision traceable back to what the rum already is, nothing added for convenience, nothing omitted for speed. The Old Fashioned format was chosen because it is the most honest template available. There is nowhere to hide in a three-ingredient stirred drink and no reason to want to hide when the base spirit is good enough to carry the format without assistance.

Expedition Spiced Rum is good enough. The Old Standard exists to demonstrate that.

The Format

The Old Fashioned's historical position as the original cocktail makes it the most instructive template available for understanding a base spirit. There is no citrus to add brightness, no liqueur to add complexity, no soda to extend the volume. What the spirit is, the format reflects back without modification. That transparency is why applying it to Expedition Spiced Rum is both a straightforward decision and a demanding one. The rum must be good enough to carry the build without assistance. The botanical profile of vanilla, cinnamon, allspice, clove, orange peel, cassia, ginger, agave, and bourbon oak, the product of real maceration with real ingredients and no artificial shortcuts, is fully present in the glass when everything else is stripped away. The Old Standard is built on that confidence.

The Demerara Decision

Demerara sugar is an unrefined or partially refined cane sugar produced primarily in Guyana, with a characteristic large crystal structure and a distinctly molasses-forward sweetness that separates it from white sugar in both flavour and application. In a cocktail context, demerara syrup produces a sweetness with depth and warmth that white sugar cannot replicate, and that depth is specifically relevant to a rum built on a Caribbean base with Welsh molasses in its foundation.

The relationship between the demerara syrup's molasses character and the molasses in Expedition Spiced's production process is not incidental. They occupy the same aromatic register and reinforce each other in the glass. The demerara syrup is not simply a sweetener in this build. It is a considered ingredient chosen because of its specific relationship to the base spirit. White sugar would sweeten the drink. Demerara deepens it.

The Bitters Logic

The split between Angostura and orange bitters in The Old Standard follows directly from the botanical profile of Expedition Spiced. Angostura's principal aromatic compounds, gentian, clove, cinnamon, and warm spice, are already present in the rum at the maceration level. Adding two dashes reinforces those notes and provides the aromatic frame the format requires without introducing anything foreign to the rum's character.

The single dash of orange bitters addresses the orange peel in Expedition Spiced's botanical profile from a different angle. Where the macerated orange peel in the rum contributes a warm, integrated citrus note, the orange bitters deliver a brighter, more volatile citrus aromatic that sits at the nose of the finished drink rather than within its body. The two forms of orange character, one deep and integrated, one bright and aromatic, produce a more layered result than either alone would achieve in this format. Every ingredient earns its place. That is the standard.

Standards Applied

The Old Standard applies the same discipline to its build that Jerry Can Spirits applies to its production. The demerara syrup is made correctly, two parts sugar to one part warm water, and stored properly. The bitters are measured rather than dashed freely. The stir is timed rather than approximated. The orange peel is expressed over the surface rather than dropped in undressed. None of these details are complicated. All of them are deliberate. The difference between The Old Standard built with attention and the same drink assembled carelessly is the difference between a drink that earns the spirit it is built around and one that does not. There is no middle ground. There never is.

How to Serve It

Stirred, strained over a single large ice cube or fresh cubed ice in a rocks glass, with orange peel expressed over the surface and rested inside the glass. No straw. No additional garnish. Serve it to those who understand that simplicity, executed correctly, is the most demanding standard of all. The Old Standard is not a drink for those who need complexity of construction to feel that something is worth ordering. It is a drink for those who already know that standards are not talked about. They are lived.

You Might Also Like

Jerry Can Spirits Expedition Spiced Rum

The Spirit

Jerry Can Spirits Expedition Spiced Rum

A premium spiced rum crafted to balance warmth, complexity, and drinkability. Featuring subtle citrus, butterscotch, caramel, black pepper, and Caribbean spices, it is designed for versatility across classic and modern cocktails.

Learn more

Need the Rum?

Pick up a bottle of Expedition Spiced Rum to make this cocktail.

Shop Now

Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits

Enjoyed This Recipe?

Explore our full collection of cocktails and discover your next favorite

Browse All Cocktails