Skip to main content
N53°49'N3°03'W52°30'N3°18'W18°44'N70°10'W50°00'N8°00'E46°00'N2°00'E65°00'N15°00'E32°00'N100°00'W37°00'N120°00'W34°00'N69°00'E52°00'S59°00'W64°00'N22°00'W72°00'N25°00'W36°00'N78°00'W25°00'N55°00'E35°30'N139°30'E1°00'N104°00'E34°00'S151°00'E
Jerry Can Spirits®

WELCOME, EXPLORER

Please confirm you are of legal drinking age in your region.

By entering, you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Illegal

Wayfinder

The Illegal is 30ml of espadín mezcal, 15ml of Jamaican overproof white rum, 15ml of falernum, a bar spoon of maraschino, 22.5ml of fresh lime juice and 15ml of simple syrup, with a few drops of egg white if you like. It is shaken hard for 10 to 12 seconds and strained into a chilled coupe, or over ice in a clay mug. About 2.5 UK units. The measures are the IBA’s. It is a mezcal sour with a rum backbone. Mezcal alone in a sour can read as ashy. The overproof rum adds fruit and force that push back against the smoke, and the falernum and maraschino bring clove, lime and cherry to tie the two together. Mixology Italia, an Italian trade magazine, says the bartender Samuele Ambrosi invented it in the late 1990s while working at the Castel Brando hotel in Cison di Valmarino. The Oxford Companion says almonds are sometimes added to falernum, so in our view it is worth checking the label before making one for anyone with a nut allergy.

Shaken

Glassware: Coupe Glass

Garnish:

Ingredients

Serves
Espadín Mezcal

30ml

At around 40% ABV. Espadín is the cultivated workhorse agave, with clean roasted smoke and enough fruit to survive five other ingredients. Rarer wild agaves are wasted under falernum and lime.

Jamaican Overproof White Rum

15ml

Unaged, at around 63% ABV. Banana, pineapple and a solvent edge with no barrel to soften it. Against the smoke that fruit reads as brightness, and the strength carries the aroma over the lime.

Falernum

15ml

At around 11% ABV: lime, clove and often almond, so check the label for nuts. It bridges the smoke and the citrus, and without it there is a gap between the base and the lime.

Maraschino Liqueur

1 bar spoon

Luxardo, as the IBA names it, at about 32% ABV. Cherry with a bitter almond edge, sweeter than it tastes, used as in a Last Word but in a far smaller measure.

Fresh Lime Juice

22.5ml

Squeezed the same day. It is the only acid against two sweeteners and a smoky base, and bottled juice shows at once.

Simple Syrup

15ml

One part sugar to one of water, by weight. Less than a standard sour takes, because the falernum is already sweetening.

Egg White

A few drops (optional)

Optional in the IBA’s recipe, and at a few drops it adds silk rather than foam. Raw. Following the FSA, British Lion-mark eggs are safe raw, including for vulnerable groups and in pregnancy; pasteurised carton white is the alternative. Eating out, where the mark cannot be checked, the FSA advises vulnerable people to have their eggs thoroughly cooked. Contains egg: leave it out, or use aquafaba, for anyone allergic.

Instructions

1

Squeeze the lime the same day.

2

Add the mezcal, overproof rum, falernum, maraschino, lime juice and simple syrup to a shaker.

3

If using egg white, add a few drops and dry shake without ice for 10 to 15 seconds.

4

Fill with cubed ice and shake hard for 10 to 12 seconds.

5

Double strain into a chilled coupe, or strain over fresh ice in a clay mug.

Source: the IBA (Official IBA specification; method ours). Last checked 10 October 2026.

Expert Tip

Keep the rum overproof. Fifteen millilitres looks like a rounding error beside the mezcal, and it carries the drink: unaged Jamaican rum at high strength is mostly fruit ester, and that fruit stops the smoke tasting of ash. A standard white rum makes a softer, duller glass. Measure the maraschino with a bar spoon and stop there. It is a loud liqueur, and a jigger of it would flatten everything else. If you add the egg white, dry shake for 10 to 15 seconds before the ice goes in. At a few drops it gives a silky texture rather than a head.

The story

Behind the Illegal

Flavour Profile

SmokeLimeCloveDry cherrysmoky

From Daiquiri to Mezcal Sour

Mixology Italia credits the Italian bartender Samuele Ambrosi, who invented it in the late 1990s while working at the Castel Brando hotel in Cison di Valmarino, after an American guest, Dr Joe Paul Shafer, spoke of his love of daiquiris. It has it beginning as a daiquiri variant with tequila, falernum, Jamaican overproof rum, maraschino, lime and simple syrup, which Shafer called illegal. Ambrosi later swapped the tequila for mezcal, at the Dom’us in Oderzo.

The IBA lists the Illegal among its New Era drinks, with the mezcal recipe given here, and Mixology Italia says it entered the official list in 2020. We have found no readable source for the story that the name comes from a mezcal brand.

Espadín

Espadín is the workhorse agave: cultivated rather than wild, and the source of most mezcal. Wild agaves such as tobalá and tepeztate are rarer and more distinctive, and a drink with five other ingredients hides what makes them worth buying. Espadín brings clean roasted smoke with enough fruit underneath to stand up to falernum and lime.

Smoke in mezcal comes from roasting the agave hearts in earth pits over hot rocks before fermentation. It is a production method rather than an additive, which is why it tastes integrated rather than applied.

The Overproof Half

Unaged Jamaican rum at overproof strength is almost all ester: banana, pineapple and a solvent sharpness, with no barrel to soften it. Against smoke that fruit reads as brightness rather than sweetness. It is the logic of an overproof float on a tiki drink, worked into the structure instead of poured on top.

A standard white rum makes a softer, duller drink. The strength is part of the recipe.

Falernum and Maraschino

Two modifiers in small measures, each meeting a different part of the base. Falernum brings lime, clove and sweetness from the same Caribbean tradition as the rum. Maraschino brings cherry and bitter almond, and at one bar spoon it is barely a measure and still clearly there.

Between them they close the gap between smoke and citrus; take either out and the middle of the drink goes hollow. Many falernums are made with almond, which matters for anyone with a nut allergy.

Beside the Naked and Famous and the Last Word

The Illegal beside our Naked and Famous and Last Word

Base

Illegal
30ml mezcal, 15ml overproof rum
Naked and Famous
22.5ml mezcal
Last Word
22.5ml gin

Liqueur

Illegal
15ml falernum, one bar spoon maraschino
Naked and Famous
22.5ml yellow Chartreuse, 22.5ml Aperol
Last Word
22.5ml green Chartreuse, 22.5ml maraschino

Lime

Illegal
22.5ml
Naked and Famous
22.5ml
Last Word
22.5ml

Syrup

Illegal
15ml simple
Naked and Famous
None
Last Word
None

UK units

Illegal
About 2.5
Naked and Famous
About 2.1
Last Word
About 2.9

The Naked and Famous and the Last Word are equal-parts drinks, where every bottle carries the same weight. The Illegal is built as a sour instead: a spirit base in front, lime and syrup to balance it, and the liqueurs as seasoning.

How to Serve It

Shaken hard and strained into a chilled coupe, or over ice in a clay or terracotta mug.

The IBA allows both. Clay cups are a traditional way to drink mezcal in Oaxaca, and a mug over ice keeps the drink cold for longer. A coupe shows off the colour and suits it served up.

For mezcal in an equal-parts drink, make a Naked and Famous; for maraschino with Chartreuse and gin, a Last Word.

Make it

Make it at home

The Spirit

Mezcal

Mezcal is distilled in Mexico from cooked agave hearts, always 100% agave under Mexico’s standard, NOM-070, at 35 to 55% ABV, and counted at 40% in our recipes. Artisanal mezcal, cooked in pit or masonry ovens, is where the smoke usually comes from. Espadín is the common agave, poured from a split base under tequila in an Oaxacan Old Fashioned to a full 60ml in a Mezcal Margarita.

Learn more
Go further

More to explore

Frequently Asked Questions

What is an Illegal cocktail?

A mezcal sour with a split base: 30ml of espadín mezcal and 15ml of Jamaican overproof white rum, with 15ml of falernum, a bar spoon of maraschino, 22.5ml of lime and 15ml of simple syrup. A few drops of egg white are optional. It is shaken and served up or in a clay mug.

Who created the Illegal?

Mixology Italia credits the Italian bartender Samuele Ambrosi, in the late 1990s at the Castel Brando hotel in Cison di Valmarino, first with tequila and later with mezcal at the Dom’us in Oderzo. It says a guest called the drink illegal, which gave the name, and that the IBA listed the mezcal recipe in 2020.

Why is there rum in a mezcal cocktail?

To give the smoke something to push against. Mezcal alone in a sour is austere and can read as ashy. Unaged overproof Jamaican rum brings fruit esters and force that fill the middle of the drink and carry the aroma over the lime.

What is espadín mezcal?

The cultivated agave behind most mezcal. It gives clean roasted smoke with fruit underneath, which is what a mixed drink needs. Wild agaves such as tobalá are rarer and more distinctive, and largely wasted in a drink with six other ingredients.

Do I need the egg white?

No. The IBA marks it optional. At a few drops it gives a silky texture rather than a foam and softens the overproof rum’s edge. If you use it, dry shake first and use British Lion eggs; leave it out for anyone allergic to egg.

Does the Illegal contain nuts?

It may. The Oxford Companion says almonds are sometimes added to falernum. Our guidance is to flag almond, a regulated allergen: check the label before making one for anyone with a nut allergy, or choose a falernum that declares none.

How strong is an Illegal?

About 2.5 UK units: 1.2 from 30ml of mezcal at 40% ABV, about 0.9 from 15ml of overproof rum at 63%, and about 0.3 from the falernum at 11% and a 5ml bar spoon of maraschino at 32%. UK units are ABV times millilitres divided by 1,000; the Chief Medical Officers’ guideline is no more than 14 units a week, spread over three or more days.

Sources.

Correct as of 19 October 2026.

  1. Mixology Italia, “Alla scoperta dell’Illegal: origini, ricetta e firma di Samuele Ambrosi” (Italian trade magazine (editorial, no byline): created in the late 1990s by Samuele Ambrosi at a newly opened luxury hotel in Castel Brando, Cison di Valmarino; a daiquiri variant for the American guest Dr Joe Paul Shafer, with tequila, Caribbean falernum, Wray and Nephew overproof rum, maraschino, lime and sugar syrup; Shafer called it truly illegal; later at the Dom’us in Oderzo tequila became mezcal; the IBA made it official in 2020 as a New Era drink).
  2. The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails (Martin Cate), “falernum” (secondary source: a traditional liqueur from Barbados; rum-, sugar- and lime-based with Caribbean spices such as cloves, ginger and nutmeg; almonds sometimes added).
  3. IBA, “Illegal” (official page: 30 ml Espadin mezcal, 15 ml Jamaica overproof white rum, 15 ml falernum, a bar spoon of Luxardo maraschino, 22.5 ml fresh lime juice, 15 ml simple syrup, a few drops of egg white (optional); listed among the New Era drinks).

Where this one sits

Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits · Updated 1 November 2026

Rate it

Enjoyed This Recipe?

First Pour

The book that comes before the bottle.

First Pour is our short companion to Expedition Spiced Rum. How it is built, how to drink it, and the first serves to try. Yours free, with 10% off your first order.