Cloudy Apple Juice
Apples pressed and left unfiltered, which is what an American recipe means by apple cider and a British one does not. There is no alcohol in it under either name, and the cloudiness is the part that carries the flavour.
Quick Facts
Flavour Profile
Primary Flavours
Tasting Notes
The whole apple rather than its sugar: flesh, skin and a soft acidity that filtered juice trades away.
Storage & Handling
Refrigerated once opened, and before opening for fresh-pressed bottles.
Shelf Life
Opened: 3-4 days refrigerated. Unopened: see the bottle; fresh-pressed keeps days, not months.
Usage
The orchard note in autumn serves, and what a recipe means when it prints apple cider in the American sense: the Stone Fence, the Hot Toffee Apple, the Fireside Punch and the Hot Spiced Cider among them. Warmed rather than boiled.
Cloudy Means Unfiltered
Clear apple juice has been filtered or fined to take out the suspended solids, and cloudy juice has not. What stays behind is pectin, fine pulp and a set of polyphenols bound up with them, and those are the parts carrying most of the aroma and the body. That is why cloudy juice tastes of apple and clear juice tastes of sweetness. The difference is more pronounced in a hot drink than a cold one, because warmth releases aromatics that a filtered juice simply does not have to release.
One Name, Two Countries
An American recipe calling for apple cider means unfermented pressed juice, cloudy and unfiltered. A British one means an alcoholic drink, usually somewhere between 4% and 7%. Nothing in either phrase signals which is meant, and the drinks that get confused are exactly the ones where it matters, since a Stone Fence made with the wrong reading is either a soft drink or twice the strength intended. The rule is to read the recipe by where it came from rather than by the words on the page.
Why It Browns
Cut an apple and it goes brown within minutes, and pressed juice does the same for the same reason. An enzyme called polyphenol oxidase reacts with oxygen and turns the polyphenols dark. Commercial juice is usually treated with ascorbic acid to slow it, which is why a shop bottle holds its colour and a home press does not. The browning is cosmetic rather than spoilage, and a fresh juice that has darkened is still perfectly good, though it will look wrong floated on top of anything.
An Acid as Well as a Sweetener
Apple juice carries malic acid, which is what gives a sharp apple its bite, and that makes it an acidic ingredient rather than a purely sweet one. It sits around the acidity of a mild orange juice, so it does part of the balancing work in a drink without needing citrus alongside it. The practical consequence is that a build using apple juice usually needs less lemon than the same drink made with a sweeter juice, and adding both makes a sour rather than an autumn drink.
Top Tips
- Choose cloudy over clear. The unfiltered press keeps the pectin and aroma that filtering removes.
- Read apple cider by its passport. In an American recipe it means this juice, and in a British one an alcoholic drink.
- Warm it gently and never boil it. Fresh apple is the point and it cooks away.
Possible Substitutions
- Clear apple juice: cleaner, thinner, a last resort in hot serves
- Dry cider where alcohol is welcome: the fermented sibling
Production Method
Apples milled and pressed, then bottled without fine filtration: the suspended fruit solids carry the cloud and much of the flavour. Pasteurised for the shelf; fresh from the press at farm shops in season.
Common Questions
Is apple cider the same as apple juice?
It depends which country wrote the recipe. In America, apple cider is unfermented cloudy juice and it is exactly this ingredient. In Britain, cider is alcoholic. The phrase carries no signal about which is meant, so the origin of the recipe decides it.
Why cloudy rather than clear?
Because the parts filtered out of clear juice are the parts that taste of apple. Pectin, fine pulp and the polyphenols bound to them carry the aroma and the body, and removing them leaves sweetness with very little behind it. The gap widens in a hot drink.
What drinks use cloudy apple juice?
The autumn and hot serves, chiefly: the Hot Spiced Cider, the Hot Toffee Apple, the Fireside Punch and the Stone Fence. It also lengthens a bourbon or rye highball, where the malic acid does some of the work citrus would otherwise be brought in for.
Why does fresh apple juice go brown?
An enzyme called polyphenol oxidase reacts with oxygen and darkens the polyphenols, which is the same reaction that browns a cut apple. Shop juice is usually treated with ascorbic acid to slow it. The colour change is cosmetic, and browned juice is still good to drink.
Featured In These Cocktails
Show all 9 cocktailsShow fewer
Often Used With
Guide by Jerry Can Spirits