Presbyterian
The Presbyterian is whiskey topped with equal parts ginger ale and soda water, and the split is the entire recipe. Ginger ale on its own makes a sweet highball. Soda on its own makes a plain one. Half and half puts the ginger at seasoning strength while keeping the drink dry and the bubbles sharp. It has been in American bar books since the 1890s and nobody has ever settled where the name came from. Temperance-adjacent wit is the usual guess, on the basis that it is a notably restrained way to drink whiskey. A Scottish reference and a private club joke are the other candidates. The books do not say and probably never did. What survives is a genuinely good drink and about thirty seconds of work. It is the highball for people who find a whisky and ginger too sweet, which is most people who have had more than one.
Glassware: Highball Glass
Garnish: Lemon Twist
Ingredients
50ml
Rye's pepper is what the ginger picks up, which is why it is the traditional choice. Scotch makes a softer, more club-room version, and bourbon makes a sweeter one that works against the point.
60ml
Half the top rather than all of it. Ginger ale is sweeter than it seems, and at full measure it flattens the whiskey underneath into a background note.
60ml
The other half, and the reason the drink works. It returns the dryness the ginger ale takes away while keeping the carbonation at full strength.
Instructions
Fill a highball glass to the top with cubed ice.
Add the rye whiskey.
Pour the ginger ale and soda water in together.
Stir once, gently.
Express a lemon twist over the surface and drop it in.
Expert Tip
Keep the split at exactly half and half. Tilting it toward the ginger ale is the obvious thing to do and it makes a sweeter, blunter drink, at which point you may as well have ordered a whisky and ginger. The whole reason this recipe exists is that somebody worked out the ratio. Pour the two mixers in together rather than one after the other. They integrate on the way down and you need only one gentle stir, which keeps more carbonation in the glass than stirring twice does. Fill the glass with ice properly. A tall drink with three or four cubes in it warms and dilutes faster than one filled to the top, which is counter-intuitive and true.
Flavour Profile
Where It Comes From
The Presbyterian turns up in American bar books from the 1890s onward with the recipe essentially unchanged: whiskey, ginger ale, soda, ice, twist. What nobody has ever established is the name.
The most repeated explanation is that it is a joke about temperance. Presbyterianism carried a strong association with abstinence in nineteenth-century America, and a drink that halves the sweetness of a whisky and ginger has a certain dry propriety to it. A reference to Scotland and its whisky is the second theory, and a club in-joke lost to time is the third. All three are plausible and none is documented, which is where the matter has rested for a hundred and thirty years.
The Split Top
The ratio is doing real work and it is worth understanding rather than just following.
Ginger ale carries a substantial amount of sugar. In a full-length highball that sugar is the dominant impression, which is why a whisky and ginger drinks like a soft drink with whiskey in it. Soda water carries none, and it brings the same carbonation.
Mixing them half and half halves the sugar without halving the fizz, and it drops the ginger from being the flavour of the drink to being a seasoning on it. The whiskey comes back forward, which in a drink with only one flavourful ingredient is the entire objective.
Which Whiskey
Rye is the traditional choice and the best one. Its pepper and dry grain meet ginger halfway, which is why rye and ginger works across the whole buck and mule family.
Scotch makes a softer version with more of a club-room character, and a lightly peated malt in particular does something interesting against the ginger without needing any adjustment. Bourbon is the one to avoid: it is sweeter to start with, and adding it to a recipe whose entire purpose is reducing sweetness works against the drink.
Why It Is Still Ordered
Very few drinks survive a hundred and thirty years without either becoming famous or disappearing. The Presbyterian has managed a third thing: it is almost unknown to general drinkers and reliably known to bartenders, who order it themselves.
The reason is that it solves a real problem. A whisky and ginger is too sweet to have more than one of. This is not, and it takes no more effort to make.
How to Serve It
A highball filled to the top with ice, fifty millilitres of rye, then the ginger ale and soda poured in together and stirred once. Lemon twist expressed over the surface.
Cold and long, and it holds its shape for as long as the ice does, which is the whole point of a highball built this carefully.
The Spirit
Whiskey (Rye)The whiskey the American classics were written for. Rye is dry and peppery where bourbon is sweet and broad, and a Manhattan or a Sazerac built on the wrong one is a noticeably different drink rather than a near miss.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Presbyterian cocktail?
Whiskey lengthened with equal parts ginger ale and soda water over ice, with a lemon twist. The split top is the whole recipe: it halves the sweetness of a whisky and ginger while keeping the carbonation and the ginger character.
Why the split between ginger ale and soda?
Ginger ale carries a lot of sugar and soda carries none, but both carry the same fizz. Half and half halves the sweetness without flattening the drink, which drops the ginger from being the flavour to being a seasoning on the whiskey.
Where does the name come from?
Nobody knows. Temperance wit is the usual explanation, a Scottish reference is the second, and a lost club joke is the third. The drink has been in American bar books since the 1890s with no origin recorded.
Which whiskey works best?
Rye, because its pepper meets the ginger halfway. Scotch makes a softer version that is also very good. Bourbon is the one to skip: it is sweeter to begin with, which undermines a recipe whose whole purpose is reducing sweetness.
Master the Techniques
You Might Also Like
Whiskey Highball
The Highball is one of the oldest and most debated drink formats in the canon, with origin stories placing it variously in American railroad culture, British officers’ messes, and the bars of late nineteenth century New York. The name most likely derives from the railway signal ball that indicated a clear track ahead, fitting for a drink fast to build and faster to consume. The format arrived in Japan in the early twentieth century and was adopted with a seriousness that turned a simple two-ingredient serve into a craft discipline. The Japanese Highball, whisky and soda water over ice in a tall glass, became one of the defining drinks of Japanese bar culture, and the attention given to ice temperature, glass preparation, carbonation preservation, and the ratio of whisky to soda made it the benchmark for the format. The version documented here applies those standards to a Scotch or Irish whiskey base. Two ingredients. The quality of each determines everything. A whiskey with genuine character and a well-chilled, high-carbonation soda, poured correctly over properly prepared ice, produce a drink greater than the sum of its parts; the format has nowhere to hide a characterless whiskey or a flat soda.
Whisky Mac
The Whisky Mac is Britain’s medicinal handshake: Scotch and green ginger wine at two to one, named by tradition for Colonel Hector Macdonald of the Raj, and prescribed against cold, damp and golf since the Victorian bottles first met. No ice historically, and no garnish ever. The build is the two-bottle canon at its most direct. The ginger wine’s fermented fire and raisin sweetness fold into malt as though the two had been cellared together, which in British households they effectively were. The ratio flexes with the weather: two to one as standard, equal parts for a genuine emergency. It sits in the ginger-and-whisky wing beside the Presbyterian’s dry sparkle, offering fortified intimacy where that one offers length, and it is the reason a bottle of green ginger wine is worth buying at the first cold snap and finishing before spring. Nobody drinks one in July, which is not a limitation so much as the whole design: a drink with a season, poured for weather that Britain reliably supplies.
Moscow Mule
The Moscow Mule is the drink that taught America to drink vodka, and it was born of two business problems having lunch. In 1941 John Martin could not sell the Smirnoff brand he had recently bought, and Jack Morgan of the Cock 'n' Bull on Sunset Strip could not sell his house-made ginger beer. They solved each other over a table. The copper mug, by the best telling, came from a third party with an unsellable stock of them. Three surpluses, one immortal drink. The build is a buck at its most direct: vodka for clean strength, fiery ginger beer for everything else, lime to hold the line. Vodka's neutrality is a commercial handicap almost everywhere and the design here: nothing interferes with the ginger and lime running at full brightness. The mug turned out to be engineering as well as marketing, which nobody involved had planned and everybody has benefited from since.
Where this one sits
Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits
Enjoyed This Recipe?
Explore our full collection of cocktails and discover your next favorite
Browse All Cocktails