American Trilogy
The American Trilogy is an Old Fashioned with two spirits in it, and the split is doing more than adding flavour. Applejack was America's first spirit, distilled from orchards before anyone was making whiskey at scale. Rye was the grain that followed it. The sugar between them came up the same trade routes as everything else. Three ingredients, three eras, which is where the name comes from. Richard Boccato and Michael McIlroy built it at Little Branch in New York around 2008. The method is the 1806 formula performed properly: a brown sugar cube muddled in the glass with orange bitters and a little water, then the spirits over one large cube and a long stir. What it tastes like is an Old Fashioned with its edges rounded off by fruit. The applejack does not make the drink taste of apple so much as make the rye taste less severe, which is a subtler result than the concept leads you to expect.
Glassware: Rocks Glass
Garnish: Orange Twist
Ingredients
30ml
Half the base, so it has to be able to hold its half. A bonded rye at 50 per cent matches the applejack in weight; at 40 per cent the apple brandy starts leading, which is not the drink.
30ml
American apple brandy, bonded if you can get it. Calvados stands in and gives a drier, more austere reading; the American styles are rounder and closer to what the recipe intends.
1 cube
Muddled in the glass with the bitters and a little water. A demerara or other dark sugar brings a molasses note that plain white sugar does not, and that note is a third of the drink's argument.
2 dashes
Two dashes rather than Angostura. Orange peel bridges the grain and the orchard, where clove and cinnamon would sit on top of both and pull the drink toward Christmas.
Instructions
Muddle the brown sugar cube with the orange bitters and a barspoon of water in a rocks glass.
Add one large cube of ice.
Add the rye and the applejack.
Stir for 30 seconds, until cold and fully integrated.
Express an orange twist over the surface and drop it in.
Expert Tip
Muddle the cube rather than reaching for syrup. It is not ceremony for its own sake: a cube dissolving through a thirty-second stir gives you sweetness that arrives gradually as the drink dilutes, rather than a fixed level from the first sip. Add a barspoon of water to start it off and be patient with it. Use real applejack if you can find it and calvados if you cannot. Bonded applejack at 50 per cent makes the best version, because a split base needs both halves at similar strength or the rye simply takes over. Do not shorten the stir. Thirty seconds is written into the spec because at twenty the sugar is still working.
Flavour Profile
Where It Comes From
Richard Boccato and Michael McIlroy built the drink at Little Branch, the Sasha Petraske bar that opened in the West Village in 2005, at some point around 2008. Both came out of the Milk & Honey school and the recipe carries its habits: exact measures, no unnecessary ingredients, and a method written down rather than improvised.
It has since become one of the more widely poured modern Old Fashioned variations, largely because it is easy to make well and because the concept can be explained to a customer in one sentence.
The Split History
Apple brandy has the better claim to being America's first spirit. Orchards were planted before grain was being distilled at any scale, and applejack, produced by freeze-concentrating cider through New England winters, was the drink of the colonies. Rye came later, as farming moved west and grain became the surplus worth distilling.
Putting the two at fifty-fifty is not a flavour decision first. It is a chronological one: colonial orchard and frontier grain in the same glass, with the brown sugar as the third element and the trade that connected everything. That the result also tastes good is what makes it a cocktail rather than a history lesson.
Why the Sugar Cube Matters
Every Old Fashioned recipe now offers syrup as the sensible modern option, and it is. It also makes a different drink.
A cube muddled with bitters and a barspoon of water does not fully dissolve when you start stirring. It keeps dissolving through the stir and, if you are drinking slowly, past it. That means the sweetness climbs gradually as the ice melts rather than sitting at one level throughout, which is why an Old Fashioned made this way tastes drier at the start and rounder at the end. That arc is what the original method produced and what syrup flattens out.
Applejack and Its Substitutes
Bonded applejack, at 50 per cent and aged at least four years under the Bottled-in-Bond Act, is the version the recipe wants. It has the weight to sit alongside rye at equal measure without being pushed under.
Calvados works and makes a drier, more restrained drink with less obvious fruit. Ordinary blended applejack, which in the United States is largely neutral spirit with a small proportion of apple brandy in it, is the one to avoid: at half the base you would be building the drink on vodka.
How to Serve It
One large cube in a rocks glass, thirty seconds of stirring, an orange twist expressed over the surface and dropped in.
It is a slow drink and it should be treated as one. The reward for stirring it properly and drinking it unhurried is that it changes as it goes, which very few Old Fashioned variations bother to do.
The Spirit
Whiskey (Rye)The whiskey the American classics were written for. Rye is dry and peppery where bourbon is sweet and broad, and a Manhattan or a Sazerac built on the wrong one is a noticeably different drink rather than a near miss.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the trilogy in an American Trilogy?
Three eras rather than three spirits: colonial applejack, frontier rye and the brown sugar that came up the trade routes between them. The name is about American drinking history rather than about what is in the glass.
Applejack or calvados?
Applejack is what the recipe intends, and bonded applejack at 50 per cent makes the best version because it matches the rye in weight. Calvados works and gives a drier, more austere drink with less obvious apple in it.
Why muddle a sugar cube instead of using syrup?
Because a cube carries on dissolving through the stir and beyond it, so the drink starts drier and gets rounder as it goes. Syrup fixes the sweetness at one level from the first sip. Both work; only one of them changes.
How is it different from a Diamondback?
Both pair rye with apple brandy, and there the resemblance ends. A Diamondback adds yellow Chartreuse and is served up at full strength. This is an Old Fashioned: sugar, bitters, one large cube, and considerably more forgiving.
Master the Techniques
You Might Also Like
Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned is the oldest documented cocktail in the American canon and the drink from which the word cocktail derives its original meaning. Its first print definition, in 1806, as a stimulating liquor composed of spirits, sugar, water, and bitters, describes the Old Fashioned before the name existed. The name came in the 1880s, when bartenders began adding fruit and soda to the format and drinkers who preferred the original asked for their cocktail the old-fashioned way. Three ingredients in their purest form: whiskey, sugar, and bitters; the expressed orange peel and the ice are conditions of the serve rather than additions. The simplicity is the entire point. Built properly, with a quality bourbon or rye, it is one of the most satisfying drinks in the canon; built badly, one of the most disappointing. Rye versus bourbon is the most common argument and the least interesting one. Both are correct. Rye produces a drier, spicier result where the bitters are more prominent; bourbon a rounder, sweeter one where the vanilla and caramel of the grain lead. What is a matter of correctness: sugar fully dissolved, bitters measured rather than dashed freely, and the drink stirred rather than shaken.
Diamondback
The Diamondback is three strong bottles and nothing else: rye, calvados and yellow Chartreuse, stirred and served up. There is no citrus, no sugar and no soda. Whatever softening the drink gets, it gets from the ice. The structure is the Widow’s Kiss with the hierarchy inverted. That 1895 drink leads on calvados with yellow Chartreuse behind it; here the rye takes the spine and the apple brandy drops to second, with the Chartreuse unchanged in its supporting role. Tasting the two in sequence is the clearest lesson available in how much a chord changes when you decide which note leads. What arrives is autumn with its collar up: orchard fruit and rye spice under the honeyed saffron of the Chartreuse, which supplies the drink's only sweetness and a good deal of its character. It is strong, and it is meant to be. This is a one-per-evening drink, and the snake it is named after is fair warning.
Improved Whiskey Cocktail
This drink is why the Old Fashioned is called the Old Fashioned. The original cocktail of the early 1800s was spirit, sugar, water and bitters and nothing else. As the century went on, bartenders started improving it with the imported luxuries arriving on the back bar: a little maraschino, a dash of absinthe, a better grade of sugar, a lemon twist. Jerry Thomas codified the result in his 1876 edition and called it Improved. Not everyone wanted it. Drinkers who preferred the plain version began asking for their whiskey cocktail made the old-fashioned way, and by the 1880s that counter-order had hardened into a name on menus. The Old Fashioned is the only classic cocktail named by a complaint, and every one poured since is technically a vote against this drink. Taste them side by side and the argument replays. The maraschino adds a dry cherry and almond glow, the absinthe threads a herbal shadow through the rye, and what you end up with sits somewhere between an Old Fashioned and a Sazerac. Improvement was a fair description.
Where this one sits
Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits
Enjoyed This Recipe?
Explore our full collection of cocktails and discover your next favorite
Browse All Cocktails