Skip to main content
N53°49'N3°03'W52°30'N3°18'W18°44'N70°10'W50°00'N8°00'E46°00'N2°00'E65°00'N15°00'E32°00'N100°00'W37°00'N120°00'W34°00'N69°00'E52°00'S59°00'W64°00'N22°00'W72°00'N25°00'W36°00'N78°00'W25°00'N55°00'E35°30'N139°30'E1°00'N104°00'E34°00'S151°00'E
Jerry Can Spirits®

WELCOME, EXPLORER

Please confirm you are of legal drinking age in your region.

By entering, you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Brandy Milk Punch

Novice

A Brandy Milk Punch is 50ml brandy, 90ml cold whole milk, 15ml simple syrup and two drops of vanilla extract, shaken hard for 10 to 12 seconds and strained over fresh ice in a double rocks glass, with nutmeg grated over the top. About 2.0 UK units. It contains milk. Milk punch is old. By the Oxford Companion’s account it was first recorded in 1688, the earliest written recipe is from a 1711 cookbook, and in 1763 Benjamin Franklin wrote down a method that added brandy and lemon to hot milk so it curdled and could be strained clear. The quick, cloudy version here is the one the American South kept: it is common in New Orleans and traditional at Christmas across the Deep South. Whole milk is the choice that matters. It carries the brandy and the vanilla and stays light, where cream would turn the glass into dessert. The nutmeg reaches the nose first, so grate it fresh.

ShakenLow-ABVBrunchClassic

Ingredients

Serves
Brandy

50ml

A cognac or another sound grape brandy at 40% ABV. Its dried fruit sits well with the vanilla and nutmeg. Bourbon gives a rounder, sweeter punch.

Whole Milk

90ml

Whole milk, cold from the fridge. Its fat carries the vanilla and holds the froth; cream makes the drink heavy and skimmed makes it thin. This is the allergen in the glass.

Simple Syrup

15ml

Sugar and water, 1:1 by weight. Older recipes used powdered sugar; a syrup mixes into cold milk without leaving grains.

Vanilla Extract

2 drops

Two drops of pure extract. It seasons the milk; more turns it into a milkshake.

Instructions

1

Add the brandy, cold milk, simple syrup and vanilla to a shaker.

2

Fill with cubed ice and shake hard for 10 to 12 seconds.

3

Strain into a double rocks glass over fresh ice.

4

Grate nutmeg over the surface.

Expert Tip

Use the milk straight from the fridge. Cold milk froths better in the shake and holds the chill without much melt, and the glass never tastes watery. Do not cut the shake short. Milk takes on air under a hard shake and comes out soft and light; under-shaken, it pours flat. Grate the nutmeg fresh, and be generous. Ready-ground nutmeg fades quickly once opened, and on a drink this gentle the aroma carries much of the flavour.

The story

Behind the Brandy Milk Punch

Flavour Profile

VanillaNutmegBrandyCreamyComforting

Where It Comes From

Milk punch has a long record. The Oxford Companion says it was first recorded in William Sacheverell’s 1688 travelogue of the Scottish isle of Iona, that the earliest written recipe is from a 1711 cookbook by Mary Rockett, and that the clarified kind was very popular in England by the middle of the eighteenth century. In 1763 Benjamin Franklin set down a method that added brandy and lemon to hot milk, so the milk curdled and could be strained off, leaving a clear punch that kept, the Companion says.

Queen Victoria issued a royal warrant to the company of Nathaniel Whisson as “purveyors of milk punch to Her Majesty”, the Companion says. In the American South the quick, cloudy kind lasted. It is common in New Orleans and traditional at Christmas across the Deep South, shaken fresh rather than bottled.

Milk, Not Cream

Whole milk is the decision the drink rests on. It carries the brandy without covering it, and the vanilla sits in its fat.

Cream makes a richer, heavier drink that tastes of dessert and hides the spirit. Skimmed milk has too little fat to hold the vanilla or the froth, and the punch tastes thin.

Against Eggnog

Eggnog and milk punch share most of their ingredients. Eggnog adds whole egg and cream, so it is thicker and richer; milk punch keeps to milk and stays light.

Brandy Milk Punch and its relatives

Brandy Milk Punch

Spirit
50ml brandy
Dairy
90ml whole milk
Egg
None
Served
Shaken, over ice
UK units
2.0

Eggnog

Spirit
30ml brandy, 15ml dark rum
Dairy
60ml milk, 30ml cream
Egg
Whole egg
Served
Shaken, in a punch cup
UK units
1.8

Clarified milk punch

Spirit
Varies
Dairy
Milk, curdled and strained out
Egg
None
Served
Clear, bottled and kept
UK units
Varies

Clarified milk punch is another drink again. The milk is there to be curdled and removed, so what reaches the glass is clear and keeps well.

Brandy or Bourbon

Brandy is the older choice. A cognac’s dried fruit and soft oak sit naturally against vanilla and nutmeg.

Bourbon makes a rounder, sweeter drink with more weight. Either works at the same 50ml.

How to Serve It

Cold and frothy, over fresh ice in a double rocks glass, with nutmeg grated over the top. Strained up into a small chilled glass, it looks smarter and warms faster.

It contains milk, so check with a guest before you pour one.

Make it

Make it at home

The Spirit

Brandy

Brandy is wine, distilled and then aged in oak, and under the retained Regulation (EC) 110/2008 the word on its own means grape brandy of at least 36% ABV, matured for six months or more. Our recipes assume 40%. It is the warm, dried-fruit base of milk punch, eggnog and mulled wine, where a sound young bottle serves better than an expensive old one.

Learn more
Go further

More to explore

Frequently Asked Questions

What is in a Brandy Milk Punch?

Brandy, whole milk, simple syrup and vanilla extract, at 50ml, 90ml, 15ml and two drops, shaken hard with ice and strained over fresh ice. Freshly grated nutmeg goes on top. It is a cold, frothy drink, not a hot one.

How strong is a Brandy Milk Punch?

About 2.0 UK units, all from 50ml of brandy at 40% ABV. The milk makes it taste milder than it is. UK units are ABV times millilitres divided by 1,000; the Chief Medical Officers’ guideline is no more than 14 units a week, spread over three or more days.

Does a Brandy Milk Punch contain allergens?

Yes, milk. It is made with whole milk, so anyone with a milk allergy, or who avoids dairy, should skip it. The brandy, syrup, vanilla and nutmeg contain none, so the milk is the only dairy in the glass.

Milk or cream?

Whole milk. It carries the brandy and the vanilla and stays light enough for a second glass. Cream makes a heavier drink closer to dessert and covers the spirit. Skimmed milk goes the other way and tastes watery, because the fat is what holds the vanilla.

Brandy or bourbon?

Brandy is the drink named here, and a cognac’s dried fruit suits the nutmeg. Bourbon makes a rounder, sweeter glass with more weight, and it is a common alternative. The measures stay the same either way.

Is it the same as clarified milk punch?

No. Clarified milk punch curdles the milk on purpose, then strains out the solids to leave a clear drink that keeps. Benjamin Franklin wrote down such a method in 1763, by the Oxford Companion’s account. This version is shaken fresh and drunk cloudy.

Can I make it ahead?

Mix the brandy, milk, syrup and vanilla the night before and keep the jug in the fridge. Shake each serve with ice as it is wanted; the froth cannot be made in advance.

Sources.

Correct as of 19 October 2026.

  1. The Oxford Companion to Spirits and Cocktails (Jack Robertiello), “Milk Punch” (secondary source: first recorded in Sacheverell’s 1688 travelogue of Iona; earliest written recipe, Mary Rockett’s 1711 cookbook; Franklin’s 1763 brandy and lemon method; the royal warrant to Nathaniel Whisson; Jerry Thomas 1862; New Orleans).

You Might Also Like

Where this one sits

Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits · Updated 19 October 2026

Rate it

Enjoyed This Recipe?

First Pour

The book that comes before the bottle.

First Pour is our short companion to Expedition Spiced Rum. How it is built, how to drink it, and the first serves to try. Yours free, with 10% off your first order.