Mezcal Margarita
The Mezcal Margarita is a Tommy’s Margarita with mezcal in place of the tequila: spirit, lime and agave syrup, no orange liqueur. That last absence is the whole reason it works. A classic Margarita uses triple sec, and orange against smoke is a genuinely difficult combination: the two occupy similar space and neither wins, so the drink ends up muddled. Take the orange liqueur out, replace it with agave syrup, and the smoke has nothing to fight. The sweetener speaks the same language as the spirit, and the lime does what lime always does. Nobody owns it. It appeared everywhere at once as mezcal reached back bars in quantity through the 2010s, and it is now on essentially every agave list. For most people it is the second mezcal drink they meet, and it is the one that makes the case for the bottle in daylight rather than after dinner.
Glassware: Rocks Glass
Garnish: Lime Wheel half and Salt Rim
Ingredients
50ml
A joven espadín with balanced smoke, at mixing proof and mixing price. The intense single-village bottles are worth drinking and largely wasted under lime and salt.
25ml
A full Margarita measure, squeezed to order. Smoke is heavy, and the lime is what keeps the drink bright rather than brooding.
15ml
Sweetening an agave spirit with agave, and the reason there is no orange liqueur here. It supports the smoke instead of competing with it, which triple sec does not manage.
Instructions
Add the mezcal, lime juice and agave syrup to a shaker.
Fill with cubed ice and shake hard for 12 seconds.
Rim half a rocks glass with flaky salt and fill it with fresh cubed ice.
Strain into the glass.
Garnish with a lime wheel.
Expert Tip
Use a joven espadín and keep the interesting bottles for sipping. Espadín is the workhorse agave, its smoke is balanced rather than aggressive, and it is priced to be mixed. A single-village tobalá at three times the money will be largely wasted under lime and salt, and the fiercer bottles turn the drink into a dare. Half-rim the glass rather than salting the whole thing. It lets the drinker choose salt or no salt on each mouthful, and it is not fussiness: salt genuinely suppresses bitterness and lifts sweetness, so the two halves taste different. If it is somebody's first mezcal drink, build it half mezcal and half blanco tequila. The smoke arrives as a note rather than a statement.
Behind the Mezcal Margarita
Flavour Profile
Where It Comes From
There is no founding bar and no named bartender, and it is more honest to say so than to invent one. The drink assembled itself through the 2010s as mezcal moved from a specialist import to something a well-stocked bar simply had, and the swap was obvious enough that it happened in a great many places at once.
What made it stick was that the Tommy’s Margarita had already become the modern default. Once the frame was agave syrup rather than triple sec, putting mezcal into it required no adjustment at all.
Why the Tommy's Frame
A classic Margarita is tequila, lime and orange liqueur, and the orange is doing more than sweetening: it contributes a distinct flavour that sits alongside the agave.
Mezcal's smoke occupies the same part of the palate and it is louder. The two do not layer, they compete, and the result is a drink where you can taste that something expensive has been added without quite being able to say what.
The Tommy’s Margarita, from Tommy's in San Francisco, replaces the orange liqueur with agave syrup. That syrup sweetens and contributes almost nothing else, which means the smoke has clear air. It is the difference between a mezcal drink and a drink that happens to contain mezcal.
Which Mezcal
Espadín accounts for most mezcal production, and joven espadín is what belongs in this drink. The smoke is present and balanced, the price is reasonable, and it is made to be poured in quantity.
The temptation is to reach for something rarer. Tobalá, tepeztate and the single-village bottlings are extraordinary, and they are extraordinary at a copita's worth of attention rather than under twenty-five millilitres of lime and a salt rim. You will pay three times as much to taste a third as much.
If the smoke is too much for whoever is drinking it, half mezcal and half blanco tequila is a legitimate build rather than a compromise.
The Salt Rim
Salt does two measurable things to a drink: it suppresses the perception of bitterness and it increases the perception of sweetness. In a smoky sour, both are useful. The smoke reads slightly less harsh and the agave syrup reads slightly fuller.
Half-rim it. A full rim commits every mouthful, and the two halves genuinely taste different enough that a drinker will want the choice. Use flaky salt rather than table salt, and run the lime wedge round the outside of the glass only, so none of it falls in.
How to Serve It
Shaken hard, strained over fresh cubed ice in a rocks glass with a half salt rim, lime wheel.
It goes with charred food better than almost anything. Smoke against smoke sounds like too much and is not: the drink's lime and salt cut through grilled meat in a way a sweeter Margarita cannot.
Make it at home
The Spirit
MezcalAgave spirit from Mexico, cooked in earth pits over hot rocks, which is where the smoke comes from. The smoke is a consequence of the cooking method rather than a quality of the plant, and that distinction explains most of what separates it from tequila.
Master the Techniques
More to explore
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a Mezcal Margarita?
Why is there no triple sec?
Which mezcal should I use?
What if the smoke is too strong?
You Might Also Like
Tommy’s Margarita
The Tommy’s Margarita was born at Tommy’s Mexican Restaurant in San Francisco, where Julio Bermejo, working his family’s floor from the early 1990s, made two changes to the house margarita that became modern doctrine: out went the triple sec, in came agave syrup, and the well tequila became 100 per cent agave or nothing. The result carries his family’s restaurant name into every serious bar on earth. The logic is like-with-like. Orange liqueur, the classic margarita’s sweetener, brings its own flavour to the party; agave syrup brings only sweetness with the plant’s own accent, which lets the tequila stand at the front of its own drink. Three ingredients, and the spirit finally audible: the Tommy’s is less a variation than an argument about what a margarita is for. It is also the drink that taught a generation to read tequila labels. Bermejo evangelised 100 per cent agave bottlings from behind his bar decades before the category boomed, and the Tommy’s remains the fastest way to taste why the words on the label matter.
Mezcal Negroni
The Mezcal Negroni is what happens when Italy’s bitterest institution meets Oaxaca’s smokiest: the equal-parts Negroni template with mezcal standing where the gin stood, smoke curling through the Campari’s bitterness and the vermouth’s plush. It emerged from the agave-obsessed New York bars of the late 2000s and became the most durable of all the Negroni variations. It works because mezcal is one of the few spirits with the personality to argue with Campari on equal terms. Gin seasons the classic Negroni; mezcal debates it, the smoke and vegetal wildness pushing back against the bitter orange until the drink lands somewhere new: darker, stranger and more insistent than its parent, while keeping the equal-parts serenity intact. For mezcal drinkers it is the category’s finest stirred showcase after the Oaxacan Old Fashioned; for Negroni drinkers it is the variation that finally justifies the word. Either road arrives at the same rocks glass.
Oaxacan Old Fashioned
The Oaxacan Old Fashioned is the drink that put mezcal on the cocktail map: Phil Ward built it at New York’s Death & Co in 2007, splitting the Old Fashioned’s base between reposado tequila and smoky mezcal, sweetening with agave and finishing with the flamed orange twist. It became the template drink of the agave revolution and the most influential Old Fashioned variation of its generation. The split base is the design: tequila carries the body and oak, mezcal arrives as smoke and wildness over the top, and neither alone makes the drink. Agave syrup keeps the sweetening in the family, the bitters bridge to the Old Fashioned’s bones, and the flamed twist’s caramelised orange oils meet the mezcal’s smoke like two campfires agreeing. For drinkers, it remains the perfect introduction to mezcal: enough smoke to understand the category, enough structure to feel at home, and the Old Fashioned’s familiar silhouette holding the door open.
Where this one sits
Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits