Skip to main content
N53°49'N3°03'W52°30'N3°18'W18°44'N70°10'W50°00'N8°00'E46°00'N2°00'E65°00'N15°00'E32°00'N100°00'W37°00'N120°00'W34°00'N69°00'E52°00'S59°00'W64°00'N22°00'W72°00'N25°00'W36°00'N78°00'W25°00'N55°00'E35°30'N139°30'E1°00'N104°00'E34°00'S151°00'E
Jerry Can Spirits®

WELCOME, EXPLORER

Please confirm you are of legal drinking age in your region.

By entering, you accept our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

Bywater

Wayfinder

A Bywater is 52.5ml of aged rum, 22.5ml of Averna, 15ml of green Chartreuse and 7.5ml of falernum, with 2 dashes each of Peychaud’s and orange bitters, stirred for 20 to 30 seconds and strained into a coupe or Nick & Nora. About 3.7 UK units, with the rum at 40% ABV. Chris Hannah devised it at Arnaud’s in New Orleans in 2007, according to Punch, and named it for a neighbourhood of that city. It is built as a rum answer to the Brooklyn. It is a stirred, spirit-heavy drink with no citrus and no juice. Bitter orange, herbs and spice sit underneath the rum.

StirredSpirit-ForwardHigh-ABVBitterAfter-Dinner

Glassware: Nick & Nora Glass

Garnish: Orange twist expressed over the surface, then discarded and Cherry dropped in or on a pick

Ingredients

Serves
Aged rum

52.5ml

Punch calls only for aged rum. Pick one with oak and weight, since Chartreuse and Averna will swamp a light bottle.

Averna

22.5ml

A dark Sicilian amaro at 29% ABV that stands in for vermouth. Another bittersweet amaro changes the drink.

Green Chartreuse

15ml

At 55% ABV it is the strongest part of the glass after the rum. Measure it exactly.

Falernum

7.5ml

Punch specifies Velvet Falernum, a rum-based bottle at 11% ABV. A syrup version is sweeter and has no alcohol.

Peychaud’s bitters

2 dashes

Added with the orange bitters before the ice goes in.

Orange bitters

2 dashes

Punch names Regans’ orange bitters.

Instructions

1

Chill a coupe or a Nick & Nora glass.

2

Add the aged rum, Averna, green Chartreuse, falernum and both bitters to a mixing glass.

3

Fill with ice and stir for 20 to 30 seconds, until the glass is cold to the touch.

4

Strain into the chilled glass.

5

Express an orange twist over the surface and discard it.

6

Drop in a cherry.

Source: its creator's published specification (Chris Hannah, published at Punch (punchdrink.com/recipes/bywater/), which names him as creator at Arnaud’s, New Orleans, in 2007; measures, method and garnish as printed there (1 3/4oz rum, 3/4oz Averna, 1/2oz green Chartreuse, 1/4oz falernum, 2 dashes each of Peychaud’s and Regans’ orange bitters)). Last checked 1 November 2026.

Expert Tip

Measure the falernum with care. At 7.5ml it is the smallest pour in the glass and the easiest to overshoot, and a splash too much tips the drink from dry spice to sticky sweetness. Express the twist and throw it away, as the method says. A peel left in keeps releasing bitterness into a drink that has plenty already. Give it the full stir. Nothing in this glass is cold or thin, and a short stir leaves a hot, harsh drink.

The story

Behind the Bywater

Flavour Profile

RumBitter orangeHerbalSpicedDry

A New Orleans answer to the Brooklyn

Punch says Chris Hannah created the Bywater at Arnaud’s in 2007, and that the drink is a distant Southern cousin of the Brooklyn. The name comes from a New Orleans neighbourhood.

What Hannah changed

Punch lays out the swaps. Whiskey became rum, to reflect the Caribbean influence on the neighbourhood. Falernum went in, a Caribbean liqueur with notes of allspice, lime and ginger. Averna replaced vermouth, bringing an orange-peel tang that nods to the Amer Picon in the Brooklyn.

How the glass balances

There is no citrus and no dilution beyond the stir, so each modifier has a job. Averna is the bittersweet body. Green Chartreuse at 15ml is the herbal edge and carries most of the strength after the rum. Falernum at 7.5ml is a spice note, small enough that it sharpens the rum rather than sweetening it.

The two bitters finish the job: Peychaud’s and orange bitters add a thread of aromatics without adding sugar.

Which rum

The specification says aged rum and names no bottle. Choose aged rum with real oak and some body, because the Chartreuse and Averna are loud and a light rum disappears behind them.

The Bywater and its stirred cousins

Bywater

Base
52.5ml aged rum
Modifiers
22.5ml Averna, 15ml green Chartreuse, 7.5ml falernum
Bitters
2 dashes Peychaud’s, 2 dashes orange

Brooklyn

Base
60ml rye whiskey
Modifiers
22.5ml dry vermouth, 7.5ml maraschino, 7.5ml Averna
Bitters
2 dashes orange

Vieux Carré

Base
30ml rye, 30ml Cognac
Modifiers
30ml sweet vermouth, 5ml Bénédictine
Bitters
2 dashes Peychaud’s

Corn ’n’ Oil

Base
60ml blackstrap rum
Modifiers
15ml falernum
Bitters
2 dashes Angostura
Make it

Make it at home

The Spirit

Aged Rum

Aged rum is rum that has spent years in oak casks, usually ex-bourbon barrels, and taken on vanilla, caramel and dried fruit; our recipes count it at 40% ABV. In our recipes it is the rum for drinks where you should taste the spirit: the Old Cuban, the Mai Tai, the Rum Sour and the punch bowl.

Learn more
Go further

More to explore

Frequently Asked Questions

Who created the Bywater?

Chris Hannah, at Arnaud’s in New Orleans in 2007, according to Punch, which prints his recipe. He named it for a New Orleans neighbourhood and built it as a rum relative of the Brooklyn.

How is the Bywater different from a Brooklyn?

Our Brooklyn is rye whiskey, dry vermouth, maraschino and Averna. The Bywater uses aged rum, Averna, green Chartreuse and falernum, so it trades the Brooklyn’s dry vermouth and cherry for Chartreuse herbs and falernum spice.

What rum should I use?

An aged rum, which is all the specification says. Look for oak and body over sweetness. The drink holds nothing but spirits and liqueurs, so a thin rum has nowhere to hide.

What can I use if I have no Averna?

Another dark, bittersweet amaro is the nearest option, though expect a different drink. Averna stands in for vermouth in this recipe, so its sweetness and bitter orange are part of the structure.

How strong is a Bywater?

About 3.7 UK units, from 52.5ml of rum at 40% ABV, 22.5ml of Averna at 29%, 15ml of green Chartreuse at 55% and the falernum. That is over a quarter of the weekly guideline of 14 units in one glass.

Coupe or Nick & Nora?

Either. Punch allows both. Chill whichever you use, because the drink is served without ice and warms quickly in a warm glass.

Sources.

Correct as of 1 November 2026.

  1. Punch, “Bywater” (recipe and history: Chris Hannah, Arnaud’s, 2007; Brooklyn cousin with rum, falernum and Averna in place of whiskey, vermouth and Amer Picon; stirred, coupe or Nick & Nora, orange twist expressed and discarded, cherry).
  2. NHS, “Calculating alcohol units” (the 14-units-a-week guidance and the units calculation).

You Might Also Like

Where this one sits

Recipe by Jerry Can Spirits · Updated 1 November 2026

Rate it

Enjoyed This Recipe?

First Pour

The book that comes before the bottle.

First Pour is our short companion to Expedition Spiced Rum. How it is built, how to drink it, and the first serves to try. Yours free, with 10% off your first order.